Tragedy and Silence in Beckett’s Endgame and Bond’s Lear
Neither Samuel Beckett's Endgame nor Edward Bond's Lear
are described by their authors as tragedies, and it seems unlikely that Aristotle
would recognise them as such. Nevertheless, both writers draw self-consciously
on elements of classical tragedy - though with different aesthetic and moral
intentions, and with strikingly different results. In this essay, I will discuss
the ways in which Beckett and Bond have adapted the model of classical tragedy,
as outlined by Aristotle, to reinvent the genre for the modern era. At the
same time, I want to explore the theme of silence. This is a key idea in both
plays, but it is interpreted very differently by the two writers in their
diverse tragic schemes.
Thanks in no small part to Beckett and Bond, tragicomedy has been the dominant
theatrical genre of the last half-century - so much so that it has become
an almost meaningless catch-all term to describe any play which combines sad
and funny elements. However, both Lear and Endgame can properly be described
as tragicomedies, as recent productions make clear. A review of the revival
of Lear at the Sheffield Crucible states: 'If Shakespeare's Lear blurred the
line between high tragedy and black comedy then Edward Bond removes that line
completely' (Highfield, 2005). Meanwhile, the programme notes for the Oslo
Shakespeare Company's Endgame advise: 'The danger any production of Beckett
faces is trying to steer the correct course between the Scylla of taking him
too seriously and the Charybdis of not taking him seriously enough' (Oslo
Shakespeare Company, 2004).
This ambiguity is succinctly summed up by Nell in Endgame: 'Nothing is funnier
than unhappiness' (p.101). In fact, the characters in Endgame comment on the
farcical nature of their unhappy existence: 'Why this farce, day after day?'
asks Nell (p.99) after the pitiful pantomime of her and Nagg's attempt to
kiss, and her words are echoed a few minutes later by Clov (p.107). To underline
the point, Beckett introduces many moments of farcical action (which are much
more apparent in a stage production than on the page). Clov's attempts to
kill a flea by pouring insecticide powder down his trousers (p.108) is a particularly
gleeful example.
For Aristotle, this would be the lowest form of comedy. According to his definitions:
'Comedy aims at representing men as worse.than in actual life' (Cooper ed.,
1997). Beckett emphatically does this: it is hard to imagine characters depicted
in a worse state than Nagg and Nell, human waste confined to a dustbin. Hamm
himself is almost as grotesque, a sick, blind and unpleasant man confined
to a wheelchair. Yet he is well aware of his role as a tragic hero: 'Can there
be misery loftier than mine?' he asks in almost his first words (p.93). 'No
doubt. Formerly. But now?' The elevated tragic heroes of Aristotle's age are
no more: Beckett makes us consider the tragedy of man in his most degenerate
state. He later mocks the conventions of classical tragedy: 'Did you never
hear an aside?'; 'I'm warming up for my final soliloquy.'; 'More complications!
Not an underplot, I trust.' (p.130). Such conventions provide a meaning and
an order which is conspicuously lacking in Beckett's absurd universe.
Hamm's blindness evokes the greatest of classical tragic heroes, Oedipus (while
simultaneously creating comedy through this juxtaposition). This is a quality
which Bond's Lear also shares. In Shakespeare's version, it is Gloucester
who is blinded. Bond changes this in order to focus the tragedy on Lear himself.
Lear's stature as a tragic hero in the classical mould is more straightforward
than Hamm's: he is a king, and the sufferings he undergoes are of a magnitude
which Aristotle would recognise. Indeed, the character of King Lear is already
firmly established as a tragic hero from Shakespeare's version, however much
Bond may depart from this.
Bond's play depends upon many of the essential elements of tragedy as outlined
by Aristotle: the 'Reversal of Fortune' (at the beginning of the play Lear
is a king ordering the building of the wall; at the end he is with the peasants
trying to tear it down), 'Recognition. a change from ignorance to knowledge'
('I knew nothing, saw nothing, learnt nothing' (p.74) Lear realises, while
his blindness, like Oedipus', gives him insight), the 'Scene of Suffering'
(too numerous to mention in what remains one of the most violent plays ever
written).
Yet Bond undercuts these tragic moments as explicitly as Beckett does. The
greatest 'Scene of Suffering' - the blinding of Lear - is also played as a
grotesque piece of comedy. The Fourth Prisoner, with his scientific device
for removing human eyeballs 'based on a scouting toy I had as a boy' (p.77),
recalls the popular literary type of the mad professor, or the quack doctor
common in commedia del arte. Bond's method here, however, is derived not from
Beckett but from Bertholt Brecht. It is an alienation device, designed to
prevent our emotional identification with the character and instead make us
consider and evaluate the situation from a detached perspective.
The cathartic emotions of pity and fear which, according to Aristotle, tragedy
should provoke is antithetical to Bond's purpose. He does not want us to empathise
with his characters' suffering on a personal level (although, as with Brecht,
the power of his writing often makes this unavoidable) but to understand and
respond to the social and political structures which have caused them. Paradoxically,
pity is the emotion which Lear claims is vital: 'You take too much pity out
of me, if there's no pity I shall die of this grief,' (p.80), 'Our lives are
awkward and fragile and we have only one thing to keep us sane: pity, and
the man without pity is mad' (p.98). ('You only understand self-pity,' Cordelia
immediately counters, forcing us to re-evaluate what Lear has just said.)
Beckett, by contrast, does invite us to feel tragic pity for his characters.
'Did anyone ever have pity on me?' (p.130), Hamm asks. On one level, this
is asked petulantly and self-pityingly. Yet it is also an appeal to the audience,
not to look down on and laugh at him and his sufferings, but to identify with
him as we would with the hero of a classical tragedy. After all, Beckett sees
Hamm and his fellow characters' situation as a representation of the essence
of all human existence: as Aristotle explains, 'pity is aroused by unmerited
misfortune, fear by the misfortune of a man like ourselves' (Cooper ed., 1997)
However, Endgame offers none of the consolations which classical tragedy provides.
For Aristotle, tragedy consists of action which must have a beginning, a middle
and an end. If nothing else, therefore, the end of the play brings us a sense
of relief because the characters' tribulations are finally over (or, in the
case of Bond's epic theatre, because we have learnt something). Edward Bond,
who is a vociferous critic of Beckett, complains: 'This is not the case with
the theatre of the absurd. Here, life has been deprived of meaning: there
is a beginning and an end, but no middle' (Bond, 2000). In fact Endgame, like
much of Beckett's work, is one long ending which never quite comes. Its title,
taken from chess, describes the final stages of a game which are entirely
predictable, and therefore meaningless.
In this case, the game continues in an interminable stalemate. Beckett denies
his characters, and the audience, the comfort of a conclusion. 'Have you not
had enough?'(p.94), 'Do you not think this has gone on long enough?' (p.114)
Hamm asks Clov. Each time Clov instinctively replies 'Yes!'. For Hamm, Clov,
Nagg and Nell, even death would be preferable to a continuation of their current
situation. When Hamm threatens to give him nothing more to eat, Clov seems
happy with the prospect of starving to death. Hamm quickly comes up with a
crueller threat: 'I'll give you just enough to keep you from dying' (p.95).
Although Nell appears to be dead by the end of the play, this cannot be seen
as any sort of closure. Chances are they thought she was dead yesterday as
well - it would be hard to tell anyway.
All of our sample essays were written by students and then submitted to us to display and help others. Thanks to all the students who have submitted their work to us.
See a list of other free English essays:
Free English Essays
Free English Literature Essays
![English Essays Phone Number](http://www.englishessays.org.uk/images/phonenumber.png)
Custom Essays
Use our custom writing services to excel in your studies and graduate with a 1st Class degree.
More about Custom Essays
Essay Marking Service
Improve your grades - let our qualified experts advise you on how to improve the overall quality of your own essay.
More about our Essay Marking Service
£5000 No Plagiarism Guarantee!
Detect plagiarism in our work and get paid £5000 and a free paper!
Learn about our Guarantees!
Our Press Articles
The Times, The Observer, BBC, ITN News, Sky News, The Independent. Read our press articles
Most Popular Pages:
Custom English Dissertations, How to Write an English Essay, Press articles about our service, Custom English Essays
How to write English essays?
Academic
English essay, Admissions essay, Cause and Effect essay, Conclusion essay, Comparison and Contrast essay, Definition essay, Descriptive essay, Expository essay, Evaluation essay, Narrative essay, Non literary essay, Literary analysis essay, Persuasive essay, 5 Paragraph essay, Photo essay, Scholarship essay
FREE English Literature essays
Free English literature essays written by students for students. English
literature essays
FREE English essays
Read some of the English essays we received from students. English
essays
English Literature in the UK
Colleges and universities that offer English Literature degrees. English Literature in the UK
Free Plagiarism Scanner!
Free scanning software to check for and detect plagiarism. Free
Plagiarism Detection Tool
Our Affiliate Program!
Sell our custom essays and get 15% commission! Affiliate
Program For Essay Resellers
Want to earn £5000 per month!
We are always looking for good research writers! Become
our research writer
Customer testimonials
We've helped many students achieve
better grades. Read our customer testimonials.